Quality Paradox And Service Recovery
 


Greetings!!

A warm welcome to e-Quality Digest, a monthly newsletter of current quality affairs.

Martin Van Bure says, “It is easier to do a job right than to explain why you didn't.” Though this is the ideal state, not all companies can achieve an error-free service at all times. In case of occasional failure, companies have to evolve effective approaches to handle dissatisfied customers innovatively and creatively. An effective service recovery system should be able to convert a dissatisfied customer into a delighted and loyal one. It has been observed that customers who have been successfully recovered not only remain loyal, but also become advocates for the company. Their word of mouth can be very persuasive in influencing potential customers to choose a company and its services.

Happy reading!

| Rate this Issue |

 Featured Article

How to Convert Dissatisfied Customers into Loyal Ones

Introduction

Customer loyalty is the biggest asset a company can boast of in turbulent times. True competitive advantage can be achieved only through excellent customer service and relentless care and attention to the customer. A crucial step in this direction is the effective management of dissatisfied customers.

Even in a perfectly run company, an occasional goof-up is normal. It could result from an accident, system failure, slip-up at quality control, or a bungling at the human interface level. But, the outcome is predictable: the customer is upset, often angry and ready to vent his spleen. You have on hand a dissatisfied customer, a virtual ticking bomb!

Do all dissatisfied customers complain?

Surveys point that only about 5-10% of dissatisfied customers complain. Think about that. If your business receives 5 complaints per year you have probably had 100 dissatisfied customers during that period! Most dissatisfied customers silently shift providers or attempt to get even with the company by making negative comments. Just imagine the widespread impact of dissatisfied customers telling hundreds of others.

Paradoxical impact of complaint resolution

Roger Nunley, managing director of Georgia–based Customer Care Institute, states, "if you have a customer who is dissatisfied or who has a complaint, and you quickly respond and satisfy that customer, that customer will be even more loyal than customers who have not complained about your product or service." Other experts also agree that 95% of dissatisfied customers will do business with you again if you resolve the complaint immediately.

Service Recovery

Regaining customer confidence and satisfaction is the need of the hour. Organisations should have a service recovery mechanism in place for this purpose. It’s a set of carefully designed strategies designed to overcome the impact of negative service experienced by customers. Consider this:

Cool Water, a pool service company, sent its representative to clean up a client’s pool. In the process of pumping up water, the employee ended up damaging a nearby limestone stairway. That stairway had been built at a cost of USD 1,200. The client’s reaction can just be imagined. However, the company did not end up losing the account. The employee contacted the landscaper who had originally built the structure and the stairs were repaired within days. This, together with a sincere apology from the company owner, led to the client appreciating the company’s service.

Following are some strategies to resolve service failures quickly and effectively.

1. Recognise the role of empowered employees

Organisations should instil a culture of empowerment that enables employees to take an independent decision to delight the customer. Customers enter the complaint process in a foul mood. If the person they first interface with does not have power to quickly resolve the issue, the situation gets worsened. Even where firms fully compensate customers for the inconvenience caused, they do not gain brownie points for the delay.

A chain of restaurants in Seattle authorises its employees to provide complimentary wine, desserts, or even meals to compensate for errors or delays that peeve customers. This helped in superior service as the issues were immediately resolved without escalating it to the manager.

2. Identify the impact of satisfied and loyal employees

Research indicates that loyal, satisfied and productive employees generate customer satisfaction. Customers prefer to do business with people who know their preferences. It is thus easy to gain customer loyalty if the staff of a company is steady. A body of steady staff offers familiarity to their customers. Creating a culture that nurtures loyalty and commitment is thus necessary.

3. Let the customers talk

Most problems arise because employees do not listen to customers. Employees need to understand that interrupting customers can put them off.

Nine times out of 10, let the customer vent, tell their story, let off steam — that automatically calms them," says Nunley.

If customers are not interrupted and allowed to have their say, two objectives can be achieved: First, it enables the employee to understand matters from the customer’s perspective. Second, it allows the customer to give vent to his anger or any other emotion, which can then be considerably reduced. Such situations require tactful handling.

4. Be empathetic

Employees should state that they have walked in customer’s shoes, and communicate it both through their expression and conversation. Their tone and body language should reinforce the feeling. For instance, imagine there is a problem with food in a restaurant and the manager approaches the customer with hands on his hips and in a harsh tone asks, “What is the problem here?” It would certainly put the customer off, and he is bound to spread a negative word among his friends. Instead, if the manager says those two little magic words: I'm sorry; it would diffuse the situation.

5. Understanding

This is the most crucial step in communication. At this stage, employees need to have an overall picture of the negative experience. In case there are misunderstandings, they should be clarified with the customer. An important point to remember over here is that one should not jump to conclusions. Only when the situation has been analysed completely from various angles should a judgement be made.

6. Solution

All efforts must be directed at resolving problems at the earliest. A customer should not be transferred to more than two people for resolution of complaints. In case such a transfer is unavoidable, the first person contacted must determine the right person to resolve the matter. If any complaint is not resolved to the customer's satisfaction, explain the future steps and post the relevant documentation.

After listening to the problem, act upon it to create a win–win situation. At this stage, the employee needs to assure the customer that the problem will be rectified at the earliest. The best bet is to deliver more than promised. For instance, if a replacement has to be made in five days, deliver it within three days to the disgruntled customer.

7. Follow-up

After resolving the conflict, employees need to follow up with the matter. Either through e-mail, post or through a phone call, employees should make the customer understand that they care. This will confirm that employees are doing everything to serve customers better.

8. Developing recovery policy

Handling customer complaints in a systematic manner is crucial. Some tips for developing successful recovery policy include:

  • Involve all levels of employees
  • Identify the most frequent types of problems
  • Analyse the root cause of the problems
  • Create step-by-step procedures for dealing with various challenges

It is important that the company keeps a log or journal of customer complaints. Additionally, there needs to be a constant monitoring of the status of complaints; for instance, the time taken for rectification. This record would enable the company to identify loopholes in the process and take corrective measures.

Endpoint

If customer problems are addressed swiftly and amicably, companies gain respect. Handling customer complaints and turning dissatisfied customers into delighted ones is not easy, but should be the prime objective. The key is to recognise employees who have the ability to handle customers well and train them. Winning back customers involves listening and responding quickly to redress grievances. The trick lies in regularly interacting with customers, providing solutions by accepting responsibility for problems and re-committing to enhance customer value. Trust transforms a dissatisfied customer into a loyal ally!

 Case Study

Purpose and approach:

This study seeks to examine service recovery processes used in an international airline. The airline focused on improving customer service and reducing costs. The main methods used were interviews, observation and company documents. The research involved identifying causes of service failure, the development of key lessons and management guidelines.

Service failure:

The company data provided the number of passenger complaints during a four-year period. Additionally, the data included the amount of total compensation paid in four years and the number of complaints that were offered compensation. Recorded complaints increased by nearly 60 per cent. The number of complaints offered compensation increased from 47 per cent in year one to 72 per cent in year four. Predictably this increase in complaints led to hike in the airline's expenditure on compensation.

The following is the list of the most frequent complaints that indicate the causes of recent service failure in the airline:

  1. Frequent delays
  2. Service interruptions caused by strikes
  3. Attitude of ground staff

Service recovery plan:

Several new approaches were initiated to improve the quality of service to increase the company’s competitive advantage. The airline’s service improvements were developed in a systematic way. The core focus was improving employees’ satisfaction. These included:

  • Monthly and quarterly meetings with cabin crew supervisors to discuss service quality issues
  • Appreciating outstanding employees’ performance by presenting gifts
  • The president of the airline signing letters of appreciation for employees

Key findings and implications:

The main finding is that effective service recovery is possible through focus on both external (customer) and internal (employees) aspects. The need to recognise the impact of employees’ contribution on delivery of quality service is highlighted.

The key implications are listed below:

  • Companies must focus on factors impacting quality of employee performance. These factors are job content, recruitment, selection, training, workplace quality and management support;
  • Practise effective employee evaluation and rewards for good performance such as cash bonuses or free tickets;
  • Empower front-line employees. This helps improve employee motivation as it makes their jobs more meaningful and interesting; and
  • Provide consistent and appropriate training to develop employee ability for improving customer service. It enhances their skills for handling the differing demands of customers.

Discussion:

The Pareto principle was perceptible in the fact that 89 per cent of customer complaints resulted from 25 per cent of the problem areas. This research data pointed out that the airline needed to address these problems in accordance with their significance.

Delays caused by technical failure could be reduced through purchase of new aircraft and a scheduled upgrade of the existing fleet. Cost in investment would be gradually offset by reduction in expenditure on compensation.

Customers perceived ground staff as having “bad attitude”. Ground staff lacked appropriate soft skills for handling customer demands. The company’s management team agreed that appropriate selection and training is needed for employees to be competent. Additionally, the airline accepted the importance of employee satisfaction. They observed an increase in customer satisfaction when the service recovery process was coupled with offering initiatives to employees.

Employee strikes causing service interruptions were due to several reasons. A single union got disbanded and several others were created in its place. Employees used unions to press their demands when they felt that the management was not considering their needs. A few discontented employees organised continual strikes. These were fostered by ineffectual management support to resolving employee dissatisfaction issues.

There are certain problems caused by external factors that are beyond the company’s control. Delays, diversions and cancellations caused by weather, air-traffic congestion, or airport issues cannot be controlled.

Conclusion:

This study has several implications for the senior management. It highlights that management focus on employee satisfaction can help achieve service recovery. The service recovery process was examined starting with causes of service failure and strategies for internal process improvement. The significant link between external and internal quality raised issues of employee recruitment and training. Dealing effectively with these issues improved the level of employee skills and motivation. Finally, the study indicates the role of reliable “personal touch” service being perceived by the airline's customers as good service quality.

 Useful links

Companies give front-line employees more power
This article examines service recovery examples across airlines, hotels and rental-car companies. The focus is on how empowering front-line employees drives successful recovery process.
http://www.usatoday.com/money/companies/management/2005-06-26-service-usat_x.htm

How To Turn An Angry Customer Into A Loyal Supporter
This article discusses an action plan for turning dissatisfied customers into loyal ones.
http://www.salesmba.com/articles1/cssp07.htm

Customer Handling and Service Recovery Benchmarking Association
A useful link that can be used for identifying the best practices surrounding complaint handling and service recovery issues. By becoming members one can access the resources.
http://www.csbenchmarking.com/chsrba.html

Books

Knock Your Socks Off Service Recovery (Knock Your Socks Off Series)
(Paperback)
By Ron Zemke
Book Description
Cancelled flights, damaged goods, botched bills, locked-up software--these are the service botch-ups that leave customers angry, disgusted...and determined to never buy from you again!
But, these mad-as-hell customers can be wooed back through skilful, planned "service recovery." And, surprisingly, customers who experience world-class Knock Your Socks Off service recovery become your most loyal customers--and are a source of continuing business for years to come.

The Profitable Art of Service Recovery
By Christopher W.L. Hart, James L. Heskett, W. Earl, Jr. Sasser
Book Description
Service companies often cannot prevent mistakes, but they can learn to recover from them and thereby retain an unhappy customer. Recovery begins by identifying the problem, then acting quickly to correct it. Most importantly, service companies should give front-line employees the authority and responsibility to do what is necessary to correct a service mistake, even if it means deviating from the rules.

 What's in the next issue

Quality and e-commerce

Powered by :